Browse All Bay Shore NY 5 Bedroom Properties for Sale

Welcome to 2206 Union Blvd, a well-maintained home in the heart of Bay Shore offering comfort, convenience, and great potential. This property features a spacious layout with abundant natural light, a functional floor plan, and generous living areas perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Ideally located near shopping, dining, major roadways, and public transportation, making commuting a breeze. A fantastic opportunity for homeowners or investors alike—don’t miss your chance to make this home your own!

2206 Union Boulevard, Bay Shore

$500,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1030527 MLS

This Colonial style home features 5 bedrooms and 2 baths, 1,488 sq ft of living space on a 4,792 sq ft lot. Needs work, priced to sell.

6 Hansen Street, Bay Shore

$899,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1029811 MLS

Welcome 1641 East 3rd Avenue, Bayshore. This spacious, expanded cape offers five generously sized bedrooms and four full bathrooms, perfect for extended family or multigenerational living. A finished basement adds valuable recreation and living space, and the large property provides endless possibilities outdoors. Well-maintained and in good condition, this home is conveniently located near shopping, major highways, restaurants, and everyday amenities. Don’t miss this incredible opportunity to own a versatile and spacious home in the heart of Bayshore.

1641 E 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore

$749,999

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1020844 MLS

Welcome to your gorgeous colonial home that’s been awaiting you!! Nicely located within 10 minutes from shopping, dining, the Bay Shore Marina, and central to all LI's major highways. This beauty sits on 0.37 acres, boasts a Cul de sac driveway and falls nothing short of spectacular. The first floor hosts beautiful gray water-proof laminate hardwood floors throughout while having an open concept design with the spacious living room, a renovated kitchen that has endless soft close cabinetry which rests on breathtaking granite countertops, a large custom pantry, stackable W/D & a doggy haven near the front door for the fur baby lovers. The dining room, fully renovated bathroom with standup shower & 1 of the 5 bedrooms are also on the first floor along with a brand new Tankless Combo gas heat & hot water system. The second floor has a brand new bathroom that has a bath tub, a vanity with double sinks, bluetooth enabled surround sound, 4 spacious bedrooms that can easily fit queen size beds in it while the primary bedroom can have a California King bed to match its large walk in closet. Last but certainly not least, the backyard is a true hostess dream!!! Right off the sliding doors from the kitchen, The magnificent backyard has a full outdoor kitchen with a hibachi grill, bbq grill, ample counter space, mini fridge and high bar seating that can be used while watching T.V The outdoor living space is covered by 2 gazebos. You also have the option to take a swim in the beautiful` large above ground pool or the hottub- the possibilities to spend time with loved ones & friends under the stars is truly endless! This home will not last-run to make your showing appointment with me today! House is being sold as-is & 90% of outdoor oasis is included in the sale.

1634 N Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore

$699,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1016661 MLS

Discover this large, expanded Cape in the heart of Bay Shore! Boasting 5 spacious bedrooms and 3 fully renovated baths, this home offers modern elegance and room for everyone—including a perfect space for mom. Just minutes from shopping, major routes, and Bay Shore’s vibrant amenities. Don’t miss your chance—schedule your private tour today!

27 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore

$899,999

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1011097 MLS

Set on an impressive .44-acre lot, this beautifully renovated residence offers the perfect blend of space, comfort, and modern design. A long, paved driveway accommodates up to 10 vehicles, providing exceptional convenience for homeowners and guests alike. Surrounded by expansive lawn space and mature landscaping, the property immediately creates a sense of privacy, openness, and curb appeal that is rarely found. A welcoming front porch leads into a dramatic entry foyer featuring soaring double-height ceilings that create a stunning first impression. From the moment you step inside, you’ll appreciate the bright and airy atmosphere, enhanced by oversized windows, abundant natural light, gleaming hardwood floors, and impressive 9ft plus ceilings throughout. A spacious formal living room is highlighted by beautiful architectural details, including archways that create a natural flow from room to room. Flowing from the living room is a generously sized formal dining room capable of accommodating large gatherings with ease, making it perfect for holidays, celebrations, and entertaining. At the heart of the home is a bright and inviting kitchen surrounded by windows, allowing natural light to pour in throughout the day. Featuring stainless steel appliances including a built-in microwave, refrigerator, dishwasher, extensive cabinetry, and generous countertop space, the kitchen is designed to accommodate both everyday living and entertaining. The open and airy design creates a seamless connection between the kitchen and surrounding living spaces, allowing conversation and activity to flow effortlessly throughout the home. Sliding glass doors provide direct access to the backyard, extending the living space outdoors. Just beyond the kitchen is an open-concept family room that serves as the centerpiece of daily living. Whether preparing meals, entertaining guests, or enjoying a quiet evening at home, the layout allows everyone to remain connected. An electric fireplace serves as a beautiful focal point, adding warmth and character to the space. Completing the first floor is a conveniently located powder room and a spacious mudroom and laundry area, offering practical functionality for today’s active lifestyles, pets, and everyday organization. Beautiful wooden staircase leads to the second level, where you’ll find four generously sized bedrooms, each offering ample closet space, hardwood flooring, and large windows that fill the rooms with natural light. A well-appointed full bathroom serves the secondary bedrooms. The oversized primary suite offers a true retreat, featuring exceptional proportions, dual closets, and a beautifully updated en-suite bathroom complete with double vanities, quality finishes, and a bright, spa-like atmosphere. Additional attic storage space provides practical storage options for seasonal and household items. The fully finished lower level dramatically expands the home’s usable living space with approximately 8.5-foot ceilings, creating a bright and comfortable environment rarely found in lower levels. Complete with a wet bar and separate outside entrance, this versatile space can easily accommodate recreation, entertaining, fitness, hobbies, media space, or a variety of lifestyle needs. Step outside to your own private backyard retreat. Set on nearly half an acre and fully fenced for privacy, the property offers an exceptional amount of outdoor space to enjoy. A spacious 30’ x 20’ deck provides the perfect setting for outdoor dining, and gatherings while overlooking the expansive backyard. An oversized attached one-car garage provides additional parking and storage. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, transportation, and everyday amenities, this home offers the perfect combination of space, quality, comfort, and convenience. A rare opportunity to own a beautifully renovated home on a substantial lot with the indoor and outdoor space today’s buyers are searching for.

40 Muncey Road, Bay Shore

$700,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1006311 MLS

Welcome to this warm and inviting Colonial in the heart of Bay Shore, where comfort, charm, and pride of ownership come together beautifully. Offering 5 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, this lovingly maintained home is truly move-in ready and designed for everyday living. Step inside and feel instantly at home with sun-filled living spaces, a flexible floor plan, and a cozy wood-burning fireplace that creates the perfect gathering place. Recent improvements include a brand-new roof and skylights, which fill the home with natural light and provide peace of mind for years to come. The spacious layout offers room to grow, work, and entertain, while the beautifully maintained property provides the ideal setting to enjoy both indoor and outdoor living. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, schools, and transportation, this home combines timeless character with modern-day convenience. A wonderful opportunity to own a beautifully cared-for Colonial in one of Bay Shore's most desirable locations. Just unpack and enjoy.

1372 Pine Drive, Bay Shore

$749,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 999571 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully fully renovated home at 125 Missouri Avenue in Bay Shore! This spacious and versatile property offers a thoughtfully designed layout across three levels. The main floor features 2 generously sized bedrooms, a bright living room, an updated kitchen, a formal dining room, and 1 full bathroom. The second level offers 2 additional bedrooms and another full bathroom, providing plenty of space for extended living or guests. The lower level includes a private den with its own bathroom, perfect for a home office, guest suite, bonus recreational space or a flexible work-from home setup. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, transportation, and local amenities, this move-in-ready home is a fantastic opportunity you won’t want to miss! Come enjoy all that Bay Shore has to offer.

125 Missouri Avenue, Bay Shore

$749,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 998362 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully updated Hi-Ranch located in the desirable Brightwaters Farms section of Bay Shore. Filled with natural light, this spacious home features gorgeous wood floors, an open and airy layout, and generously sized rooms throughout. Perfect for entertaining guests, the flexible floor plan offers ideal living space with comfort and versatility in mind. The bright sun-filled interior creates a warm and inviting atmosphere, while the updated finishes make this home truly move-in ready. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, parks, and transportation, this Brightwaters Farms gem offers the perfect blend of space, style, and location. Don’t miss this incredible opportunity!

1391 N Windsor Avenue, Bay Shore

$749,998

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 994074 MLS

Spacious approximately 2,100 sq ft Hi-Ranch offering exceptional flexibility and versatile living space in Bay Shore. This unique property features a converted garage area that expands the functional footprint of the home and creates a wide range of potential uses depending on a buyer’s needs and any required approvals. BRAND NEW 30 year ROOF! The flexible layout may appeal to buyers seeking additional workspace, recreational space, home office setup, guest accommodations, hobby space, or potential accessory apartment opportunities with proper permits and municipal approvals. The property may also suit buyers exploring live/work possibilities or those needing adaptable space for changing lifestyle needs. Interior features include an updated chef’s kitchen with quartz countertops, center island, stainless steel appliances, recessed lighting, crown molding, smart thermostat technology, and an open-concept flow ideal for everyday living and entertaining. Additional highlights include 5 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, hardwood flooring, ductless cooling, natural gas heating, and generous storage throughout. Situated on an oversized property with ample driveway parking, EV charging capability, and convenient access to shopping, dining, parks, transportation, and major roadways. A versatile property offering flexibility, functionality, and opportunity for a variety of living arrangements and future possibilities.

229 New York Avenue, Bay Shore

$835,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 995354 MLS

Don't miss this Diamond in the rough which features a Bay Shore address and coveted Islip Schools. This turn-key, expansive Hi-Ranch is set on a quarter-acre of property, offering 5 bedrooms and 4 full baths with exceptional potential and space. Designed for comfortable living and perfect for entertaining, the home features a beautifully updated chefs kitchen, newly renovated bathrooms, a sun-drenched sunroom, and a spacious primary suite. The spacious lower level offers additional living areas, ideal for Mom or extended family. Step outside to a private backyard oasis complete with a pool and oversized deck — perfect for summer gatherings and outdoor enjoyment. Home is very well maintained and in Pristine condition - Offers picturesque landscaping with mature Arborvitaes lining the backyard for the ultimate feel of privacy. Also includes a brand new gas boiler & Hot Water heater, Roof is 7 years old & the roof on Sunroom was replaced in 2025. Ideally located near Bay Shore’s vibrant Main Street, South Shore beaches, and Fire Island ferries, this home offers a lifestyle of convenience and coastal charm. A rare opportunity to create your dream home with ample space for extended family.

188 Geneva Street, Bay Shore

$740,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 990474 MLS

Welcome to this beautiful Colonial located at 1433 Manatuck Blvd in Bay Shore, offering a perfect blend of comfort and functionality. This home features 5 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and 1 half bathroom, along with an open kitchen, a formal dining room, and a family room, ideal for entertaining and everyday living. The first floor showcases hardwood flooring, while the second floor offers durable laminate flooring. Additional highlights include an attached garage, in-unit washer and dryer, and pull-down stairs to the attic for extra storage. Enjoy outdoor living with a patio and deck, a fully fenced yard, and an in-ground sprinkler system. The home is equipped with natural gas heating and wall unit cooling, providing year-round comfort. Conveniently located near schools, shopping, and public transportation, making daily living and commuting easy. A wonderful opportunity to own a very spacious home with great features in a desirable Bay Shore location, don’t miss it!

1433 Manatuck Boulevard, Bay Shore

$999,999

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 977405 MLS

Nestled in the coveted Penataquit Point community, this impressive Bay Shore residence offers sweeping views of the Great South Bay and a lifestyle of comfort and elegance. With five generously sized bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite complete with a private bath and dressing area, this home is designed to accommodate both privacy and ease of living. A bright and open kitchen with ample dining space leads directly to an expansive deck, setting the stage for seamless indoor-outdoor living. The backyard is perfectly suited for entertaining or quiet relaxation, framed by natural beauty & plenty of room for a pool. Inside, you'll find a spacious living room that connects effortlessly to the formal dining area—ideal for hosting. A cozy three-season room adds charm and versatility, providing a peaceful retreat throughout much of the year. Additional features include a wood-burning fireplace, a family room with wet bar, and a flexible bonus space that functions well as a home office or gym. The property also includes a large circular driveway and a detached 2.5-car garage, offering abundant parking. A separate entrance adds convenience for multigenerational living or visiting guests. Located just minutes from Fire Island ferries and local amenities, 146 Awixa Avenue is a rare offering in one of Bay Shore’s most desirable waterfront neighborhoods. **Renderings of Possible Kitchen Renovation Concepts & Pool Placement Options**

146 Awixa Avenue, Bay Shore

$899,999

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 980412 MLS

Beautiful, excellent, mint condition, updated every place. Ready to move in. 5 Bedrooms house, detached, living room, dining room, big updated kitchen. Central air condition, heating, new roof, new siding, new windows, new flooring, new bathroom.

47 Drayton Avenue, Bay Shore

$3,350,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 973534 MLS

To-be-built remarkable colonial on one of the most beautiful and sought-after streets in Bay Shore, set on just shy of 1.5 acres with stunning water views of the Great South Bay from the second level. This exceptional 5-bedroom, 4 full bath, 1 half bath residence will feature thoughtfully designed living space and the rare opportunity for full customization, allowing the buyer to tailor every detail to their taste and lifestyle. Proposed features include 10ft first floor ceilings, a state-of-the-art chef's kitchen connecting to a formal dining room through the butler's pantry, additional breakfast room, family room with gas fireplace, spacious great room with gas fireplace- perfect for everyday living and entertaining. A stunning sunroom filled with abundant natural light creates the perfect place to relax while enjoying the surrounding beauty. The home will also feature a charming second-floor balcony overlooking the bay attached to a large master suite with his and her closets, walk in closets in the additional bedrooms, a laundry room on the second level, and beautiful carport, perfect for bringing in groceries, and a detached two-car garage. A truly unique opportunity to build your dream home in a premier Bay Shore location.

100 Awixa Avenue, Bay Shore

$625,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 968538 MLS

Welcome to 1081 Bay Shore Ave, a spacious Hi-Ranch home offering comfort, functionality and style! This beautiful property features 5 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms , an open concept kitchen that flows into a formal dining room and living room. The lower level offers flexible living space with a separate outside entrance and potential for accessory use with proper permits. The property offers a spacious deck overlooking a Koi Pond, and a beautiful yard perfect for entertaining. This home is move in ready with plenty of space and possibilities.

1081 Bay Shore Avenue, Bay Shore

$1,195,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 960290 MLS

Spacious 5-Bedroom Splanch in Desirable Bay Shore. Welcome to this expansive and well-appointed 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath Splanch offering incredible space, versatility, and comfort. Set on a beautifully maintained property, this home features multiple levels of living designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The main level welcomes you with a bright entry foyer and generous living space. The sun-filled living room with fireplace and large picture window creates a warm and inviting atmosphere, while the formal dining room provides the perfect setting for hosting holidays and special occasions. The eat-in kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, ample counter space, double wall ovens, and a functional layout that opens seamlessly to the main living areas. The upper levels feature spacious bedrooms, including a primary suite with private bath and excellent closet space. With five true bedrooms, this home provides flexibility for extended family, guests, or a dedicated home office setup. Three full bathrooms and an additional half bath offer convenience for a busy household. The lower level den provides additional living space — ideal for a family room, media area, or playroom. Step outside to a large, private backyard surrounded by mature landscaping and your fenced-in inground pool— perfect for entertaining or relaxing.

890 Thompson Drive, Bay Shore

$625,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 966198 MLS

Welcome to this beautiful colonial offering 5 bedrooms, living room, kitchen, 2 baths, 1 car garage and fully fenced yard don't miss this opportunity to own this property WONT LAST!

1520 N Thompson Drive, Bay Shore

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

5 Bedroom Bay Shore Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for 5 bedroom properties available in Bay Shore and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!