Sign up to stay up to date on the Bay Shore Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
18 Hemlock Lane 4 2 N/A $850,000 Unknown 2 days
1705 N Gardiner Drive 4 2 1,609 $599,000 $372 3 days
1545 Baldwin Boulevard 3 2 N/A $549,999 Unknown 3 days
1017 Fire Island Avenue 3 1 1,170 $479,990 $410 3 days
1346 Pine Acres Boulevard 5 2 N/A $699,000 Unknown 4 days
253 Helm Lane 4 3 1,508 $999,000 $662 5 days
253 Helm Lane Unit #253 4 3 1,508 $999,000 $662 5 days
1013 Joselson Avenue 4 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 7 days
19 Bay Shore Avenue 31 16 N/A $4,250,000 Unknown 9 days
49 1st Avenue 9 3 N/A $925,000 Unknown 9 days
24 Lakeview Avenue 6 4 2,720 $895,000 $329 9 days
19 Bay Shore Avenue 6 3 N/A $899,000 Unknown 9 days
25 2nd Avenue 3 2 1,918 $595,000 $310 9 days
23 2nd Avenue 4 2 2,055 $550,000 $267 9 days
21 2nd Avenue 3 2 1,386 $550,000 $396 9 days
1438 Lincoln Boulevard 3 2 1,300 $590,000 $453 10 days
1137 Namdac Avenue 6 2 N/A $749,999 Unknown 10 days
1728 N Thompson Drive 7 2 3,556 $298,888 $84 10 days
68 Johnson Lane 4 2 2,128 $449,999 $211 11 days
1385 Gardiner Drive 3 2 1,804 $689,000 $381 11 days
9 Harrison Place 2 1 N/A $359,900 Unknown 12 days
319 Asharoken Boulevard 4 2 N/A $620,000 Unknown 12 days
6 Southwood Court Unit #6 4 3 3,226 $1,200,000 $371 13 days
11 Indiana Avenue 5 3 1,582 $639,990 $404 13 days
29 20th Avenue 3 1 N/A $369,900 Unknown 13 days
1162 E 3rd Avenue 3 2 1,288 $469,900 $364 15 days
193 W Main Street N/A N/A N/A $3,250,000 Unknown 18 days
59 Bardolier Lane 3 2 N/A $679,000 Unknown 18 days
304 Center Oaks Trail 4 3 N/A $789,000 Unknown 19 days
1013 Spur Drive 3 2 N/A $799,999 Unknown 21 days
1156 E 3rd Avenue 2 1 N/A $475,000 Unknown 20 days
1112 Oakneck Road 4 4 N/A $819,000 Unknown 23 days
11 Admirals Drive E Unit #11 3 3 2,213 $899,000 $406 23 days
1832 Wells Drive 6 3 3,000 $649,900 $216 25 days
1062 Manor Lane 4 3 N/A $679,000 Unknown 25 days
5 Cottage Avenue 4 2 N/A $639,000 Unknown 25 days
19A Girard Avenue 4 3 2,273 $975,000 $428 25 days
8 Cottage Avenue 2 2 N/A $850,000 Unknown 30 days
No address 3 1 1,239 $549,000 $443 31 days
14 S Park Avenue 4 3 N/A $869,900 Unknown 32 days
50 Park Avenue N/A N/A N/A $700,000 Unknown 32 days
83 Harbour Lane Unit #83 4 3 2,669 $1,099,000 $411 32 days
1377 Lombardy Boulevard 5 2 6,534 $630,000 $96 33 days
1547 N Thompson Drive 3 1 N/A $499,000 Unknown 39 days
1918 Union Boulevard N/A N/A N/A $1,400,000 Unknown 40 days
981 Hampshire Road 4 3 2,671 $899,000 $336 21 days
12 Charles Street 4 2 N/A $525,000 Unknown 49 days
10 Post Lane N/A N/A N/A $450,000 Unknown 51 days
1435 Pine Acres Boulevard 3 1 N/A $599,000 Unknown 50 days
88 W Main Street N/A N/A N/A $1,600,000 Unknown 51 days
Average: 4.2 2.4 2,524 $843,527 $370 89 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 91
Viewing 1 - 50 of 91
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
151 Boathouse Lane Unit #151 3 3 1,941 $774,999 $399 7 days
10 S 3rd Street 3 1 1,100 $418,700 $380 8 days
1460 Peters Boulevard 3 2 1,686 $469,988 $278 15 days
1353 Gardiner Drive 4 2 N/A $650,000 Unknown 11 days
1135 Bay Shore Avenue 3 1 1,198 $490,000 $409 25 days
1400 E 3rd Avenue 4 2 N/A $685,000 Unknown 25 days
15 Doral Lane Unit #15 2 1 N/A $450,000 Unknown 21 days
34 Redmond Avenue 3 2 N/A $499,000 Unknown 7 days
163 Anchor Lane Unit #163 3 3 N/A $1,189,000 Unknown 33 days
2 Breslau Street 3 2 2,330 $649,000 $278 22 days
1049 Udall Road 2 1 N/A $475,000 Unknown 18 days
121 Harrisburg Street 6 3 N/A $674,999 Unknown 25 days
27 Oakland Avenue 2 1 N/A $475,000 Unknown 30 days
1095 Nugent Avenue 3 1 N/A $589,000 Unknown 38 days
5 W Belmont Street 5 2 N/A $579,000 Unknown 20 days
58 Smith Avenue Unit #58 3 2 1,700 $425,000 $250 5 days
1058 Callahan Street 4 4 2,100 $699,000 $332 9 days
1138 Namdac Avenue 3 2 N/A $510,000 Unknown 39 days
67 Beldon Lane 4 2 N/A $659,000 Unknown 27 days
86 Atlanta Street 7 4 N/A $749,999 Unknown 23 days
1744 Asharoken Boulevard 4 2 N/A $549,000 Unknown 21 days
1106 Namdac Avenue 4 4 3,706 $899,999 $242 1 day
311 Center Oaks Trail 4 3 N/A $799,000 Unknown 10 days
11 Muncey Road 4 2 2,273 $635,000 $279 26 days
7 West Court 4 2 N/A $499,999 Unknown 41 days
1861 Heckscher Avenue 6 4 N/A $525,000 Unknown 15 days
80 Ocean Avenue 5 4 N/A $569,900 Unknown 43 days
55 Johnson Lane 5 3 3,000 $799,000 $266 34 days
32 Jensen Road 6 3 2,003 $629,999 $314 50 days
106 Penataquit Avenue 4 2 N/A $520,000 Unknown 18 days
109 New Jersey Avenue 3 2 N/A $550,000 Unknown 12 days
8 Pinebrook Place Unit #8 2 1 978 $299,000 $305 43 days
1528 N Gardiner Drive 3 2 N/A $525,000 Unknown 19 days
8 Oakmont Lane Unit #8 3 4 1,997 $795,000 $398 26 days
1037 Carll Drive 3 2 N/A $569,999 Unknown 31 days
1326 Pine Drive 2 1 650 $400,000 $615 5 days
52 Lanier Lane 4 3 2,092 $699,000 $334 23 days
1080 Gardiner Drive 3 2 N/A $629,000 Unknown 53 days
1047 Nugent Avenue 3 2 N/A $595,000 Unknown 31 days
10 Cortina Way 3 2 N/A $525,000 Unknown 11 days
1332 Illinois Avenue 4 3 1,473 $589,000 $399 26 days
1386 Ohio Avenue 3 2 N/A $589,000 Unknown 14 days
145 N Penataquit Avenue 6 2 1,920 $735,000 $382 60 days
31 E Belmont Street 4 2 N/A $589,000 Unknown 155 days
45 Huron Drive 4 2 N/A $550,000 Unknown 23 days
5 Beaulieu 4 2 3,000 $459,000 $153 22 days
91 Harbour Lane Unit #91 3 2 N/A $830,000 Unknown 62 days
7 Kenneth Lane 4 2 1,350 $499,990 $370 7 days
22 Cherokee Drive 2 1 N/A $425,000 Unknown 20 days
52 S Ocean Avenue 5 3 N/A $795,000 Unknown 369 days
Average: 3.8 2.3 2,284 $608,188 $336 53 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 122
Viewing 1 - 50 of 122
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
111 King Street 4 2 N/A $630,000 $643,000 Unknown 17 days 10/11/24
1091 Courtland Drive 2 2 927 $499,999 $525,000 $566 15 days 10/10/24
1051 Thompson Drive 3 1 900 $460,000 $510,000 $566 24 days 10/10/24
12 Lee Avenue 5 3 N/A $699,990 $725,000 Unknown 13 days 10/10/24
34 Torrey Pine Lane Unit #34 2 3 1,494 $595,000 $625,000 $418 19 days 10/8/24
1422 Potter Boulevard 3 2 1,442 $575,000 $580,000 $402 118 days 10/8/24
17 Claremont Avenue 4 2 N/A $479,999 $530,000 Unknown 18 days 10/7/24
2 Warwick Lane 5 3 3,641 $879,900 $890,000 $244 15 days 10/4/24
1086 Courtland Drive 5 2 N/A $629,000 $635,290 Unknown 28 days 10/4/24
27 Montauk Drive 3 2 1,520 $599,000 $615,000 $404 14 days 10/4/24
1015 Martinstein Avenue 3 1 N/A $529,900 $540,000 Unknown 16 days 10/3/24
56 Fitchburg Street 6 4 N/A $700,000 $695,000 Unknown 105 days 10/3/24
74 Belford Avenue 4 1 N/A $369,000 $427,000 Unknown 4 days 10/2/24
6 Rowe Place 2 2 N/A $499,000 $531,000 Unknown 22 days 10/1/24
84 Harbour Lane Unit #84 3 2 2,341 $849,000 $850,000 $363 6 days 10/1/24
18 Auburn Avenue 3 3 1,791 $674,000 $660,000 $368 33 days 10/1/24
80 7th Street 3 2 2,200 $649,990 $650,000 $295 23 days 10/1/24
930 Gardiner Drive 3 2 N/A $599,000 $651,000 Unknown 20 days 9/30/24
1405 Lombardy Boulevard 2 1 1,532 $499,900 $489,000 $319 54 days 9/30/24
18 Wenman Avenue 2 1 N/A $359,000 $385,000 Unknown 25 days 9/30/24
66 Penataquit Avenue 5 1 N/A $625,000 $645,000 Unknown 14 days 9/27/24
5 20th Avenue 3 2 1,706 $510,000 $530,000 $310 119 days 9/27/24
4 S Cardinal 5 2 N/A $609,900 $495,000 Unknown 121 days 9/27/24
21 Pinebrook Place Unit #21 1 1 782 $274,900 $270,000 $345 11 days 9/26/24
1059 Carll Drive 4 1 1,260 $435,000 $470,000 $373 29 days 9/26/24
1610 N Gardiner Drive 4 2 N/A $500,000 $560,000 Unknown 21 days 9/25/24
1 Captains Walk Unit #1 3 3 N/A $689,000 $689,000 Unknown 325 days 9/25/24
50 Cedar Drive 3 2 N/A $599,999 $585,000 Unknown 57 days 9/24/24
49 West Lane 6 6 3,658 $1,500,000 $1,500,000 $410 10 days 9/24/24
1161 Hyman Avenue 4 2 1,900 $579,900 $610,000 $321 10 days 9/23/24
139 Queen Street 3 2 936 $479,999 $550,000 $587 70 days 9/23/24
19 Amfer Court 5 2 1,823 $549,000 $650,000 $356 2 days 9/23/24
43 Admirals Drive E Unit #43 2 2 1,793 $674,000 $777,000 $433 7 days 9/20/24
1230 Fairbanks Avenue 4 3 N/A $629,000 $650,000 Unknown 19 days 9/20/24
115 N Park Avenue 4 2 N/A $469,000 $490,000 Unknown 32 days 9/20/24
946 Gardiner Drive 3 2 N/A $675,000 $675,000 Unknown 30 days 9/19/24
59 Pinebrook Place Unit #59 1 1 N/A $244,900 $244,900 Unknown 32 days 9/18/24
190 Missouri Avenue 3 1 936 $545,000 $545,000 $582 61 days 9/18/24
61 S Clinton Avenue 4 3 N/A $629,999 $650,000 Unknown 34 days 9/17/24
901 Gardiner Drive 5 4 N/A $1,249,000 $1,249,000 Unknown 25 days 9/16/24
1544 Baldwin Boulevard 3 2 1,670 $549,000 $590,000 $353 12 days 9/13/24
1526 Potter Boulevard 3 2 N/A $565,000 $610,000 Unknown 13 days 9/13/24
26 Abingdon Avenue 3 2 N/A $510,000 $560,000 Unknown 14 days 9/13/24
26 Benjamin Street 4 2 N/A $349,900 $408,000 Unknown 4 days 9/12/24
194 Captains Way Unit #194 2 3 N/A $739,000 $704,000 Unknown 78 days 9/12/24
23 Chapman Place 5 2 N/A $699,990 $675,000 Unknown 19 days 9/12/24
325 Pine Drive 4 2 1,762 $799,000 $775,000 $439 84 days 9/11/24
75 S Saxon Avenue 5 4 4,200 $699,000 $700,000 $166 70 days 9/11/24
90 E Lakeland Street 3 1 N/A $505,000 $502,250 Unknown 25 days 9/10/24
96 Orleans Street 4 2 1,552 $599,999 $655,000 $422 7 days 9/10/24
Average: 3.7 2.2 2,208 $601,597 $617,595 $355 41 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 201
Viewing 1 - 50 of 201

Information Copyright 2024, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.