Sign up to stay up to date on the Bay Shore Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
1566 Lincoln Boulevard 4 3 N/A $549,000 Unknown 0 days
263 4th Avenue 2 2 N/A $399,000 Unknown 1 day
Lot 5&6 Overlea N/A N/A N/A $2,500,000 Unknown 1 day
Lot 5 Overlea N/A N/A N/A $1,200,000 Unknown 1 day
353 Pennsylvania Avenue 4 2 N/A $605,000 Unknown 1 day
Lot 6 Overlea N/A N/A N/A $1,600,000 Unknown 1 day
2 Pinebrook Place 2 1 900 $275,000 $305 1 day
1600 Baldwin Boulevard 5 2 2,100 $479,900 $228 3 days
3 Beech Pl Place 3 1 1,500 $445,000 $296 1 day
1443 Forks Road 3 2 N/A $499,999 Unknown 0 days
1056 Cassel Avenue 4 3 2,815 $775,000 $275 3 days
41 Chenango Drive 3 2 N/A $360,000 Unknown 0 days
1363 Ackerson Boulevard 3 2 N/A $469,900 Unknown 3 days
906 Gardiner Drive 5 5 3,850 $869,000 $225 2 days
116 Baltimore Street 4 2 N/A $499,000 Unknown 4 days
779 Spur Dr N 3 2 N/A $489,999 Unknown 6 days
1429 Peters Boulevard 4 2 N/A $529,999 Unknown 6 days
109 Oakdale Street 4 3 N/A $559,900 Unknown 6 days
1009 Thompson Drive 4 3 N/A $640,000 Unknown 6 days
976 Gardiner Drive 3 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 6 days
102 Penataquit Avenue 3 3 3,000 $879,999 $293 3 days
101 Penataquit Avenue 4 3 N/A $1,175,000 Unknown 7 days
1408 3rd Avenue 3 2 N/A $379,000 Unknown 7 days
1035 Thompson Drive 4 2 1,680 $649,000 $386 8 days
lot 4 Overlea N/A N/A N/A $799,990 Unknown 8 days
1316 Windsor Avenue 4 3 1,912 $625,000 $326 7 days
89 Greenwood Road 3 2 N/A $489,900 Unknown 8 days
1401 Brook Avenue 4 3 2,088 $579,000 $277 9 days
9D Hemlock Drive Unit #34 1 1 N/A $145,000 Unknown 9 days
1121 Hyman Avenue 4 3 N/A $569,000 Unknown 8 days
1621 Thompson Drive 6 4 N/A $599,990 Unknown 6 days
2 Gateway Drive 3 2 1,582 $599,990 $379 10 days
1322 Pine Acres Boulevard 4 2 1,650 $459,500 $278 11 days
90 Clinton Avenue 3 2 N/A $549,000 Unknown 13 days
109 Huron Drive 3 2 1,600 $499,000 $311 13 days
185 Captain's Way Unit #185 3 3 2,803 $950,000 $338 5 days
19 Bay Shore Road 3 1 984 $450,000 $457 14 days
1547 Brightshore Boulevard 4 2 2,322 $375,000 $161 14 days
1387 Pine Acres Boulevard 4 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 14 days
1054 Ocean Avenue 4 2 1,536 $379,900 $247 14 days
44 Smith Avenue Unit #NA 3 2 N/A $399,000 Unknown 14 days
1002 Carll S Drive 3 2 N/A $495,000 Unknown 5 days
6 Henry Place 3 1 N/A $399,999 Unknown 8 days
1521 Thompson Drive 4 2 N/A $499,000 Unknown 5 days
291 4th Avenue 3 2 N/A $499,999 Unknown 16 days
219 Brentwood Street 4 2 N/A $449,000 Unknown 17 days
153 Awixa Avenue 6 5 6,500 $1,799,000 $276 5 days
220 Gunther Avenue 3 2 N/A $450,000 Unknown 73 days
1054 Sullivan Street 4 2 N/A $549,000 Unknown 13 days
20 Doral Lane Unit #20 4 3 2,200 $679,000 $308 16 days
Average: 3.6 2.3 2,761 $754,451 $318 116 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 118
Viewing 1 - 50 of 118
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
1004 Howells Road 5 3 3,828 $649,990 $169 12 days
1138 Hyman Avenue 3 2 N/A $549,000 Unknown 7 days
1724 Gardiner Drive 5 2 N/A $540,000 Unknown 5 days
1469 Lincoln Boulevard 3 2 N/A $479,000 Unknown 4 days
23 Sunset Road 4 3 N/A $699,000 Unknown 1 day
9 Henry Place 2 1 N/A $379,999 Unknown 5 days
20 Montauk Drive 3 2 1,200 $519,900 $433 6 days
1066 Carll Drive 4 4 N/A $575,000 Unknown 18 days
1690 Westwood Boulevard 3 1 N/A $375,000 Unknown 26 days
603 Asharoken Boulevard 3 2 N/A $650,000 Unknown 5 days
12 W Shore Road 3 2 2,100 $725,000 $345 4 days
1085 Brookdale Avenue 4 3 N/A $459,999 Unknown 5 days
1534 Brightshore Boulevard 3 1 942 $429,999 $456 15 days
1059 Courtland Drive 3 1 N/A $469,000 Unknown 4 days
6 Harrison Avenue 1 2 700 $275,000 $392 26 days
107 Queen Street 3 2 1,565 $489,000 $312 7 days
48 Belmont Street 3 1 1,200 $499,999 $416 35 days
1012 Thompson Drive 2 2 N/A $499,900 Unknown 15 days
1375 Thompson Drive 3 2 N/A $439,900 Unknown 23 days
114 1st Avenue 3 1 1,000 $325,000 $325 25 days
20 Duke Street 3 2 1,032 $399,999 $387 15 days
7 Joyces Way Unit #7 2 3 1,600 $499,000 $311 6 days
1410 Windsor Avenue 2 2 N/A $349,999 Unknown 11 days
179 5th Avenue 5 3 N/A $519,000 Unknown 36 days
1805 Stein Drive 5 4 N/A $650,000 Unknown 28 days
31 Smith Avenue Unit #31 3 2 N/A $399,000 Unknown 12 days
1140 Hyman Avenue 3 3 N/A $499,000 Unknown 38 days
1407 Illinois Avenue 4 2 1,510 $550,000 $364 7 days
1056 Martinstein Avenue 3 1 1,080 $399,999 $370 10 days
17 Homan Place 3 2 N/A $519,000 Unknown 22 days
1457 Potter Boulevard 3 1 N/A $450,000 Unknown 21 days
100 Mystic Circle Unit #1 2 3 1,847 $499,000 $270 7 days
6 Runyon Street 5 3 2,148 $675,000 $314 7 days
601 Asharoken Blvd 2 1 N/A $399,999 Unknown 4 days
9 Lockwood Road 2 1 N/A $385,000 Unknown 13 days
841 Aberdeen Road 4 3 4,092 $999,999 $244 7 days
43 Indiana Avenue 3 2 N/A $389,000 Unknown 5 days
186 Missouri Avenue 7 4 N/A $719,000 Unknown 14 days
14 Farragut Avenue 4 2 1 $480,000 Unknown 15 days
1341 Elayne Avenue 4 2 1,500 $549,990 $366 12 days
980 Manor Lane 4 2 2,400 $699,000 $291 20 days
1393 Lombardy Boulevard 3 2 N/A $500,000 Unknown 11 days
44 Center Avenue 3 2 N/A $399,000 Unknown 19 days
23 23rd Avenue 3 2 N/A $525,000 Unknown 9 days
1093 Oakneck Road 4 3 2,373 $589,000 $248 4 days
412 Asharoken Boulevard 3 1 N/A $449,900 Unknown 42 days
1412 Peters Boulevard 3 2 1,800 $499,000 $277 9 days
1449 Ackerson Boulevard 3 2 N/A $449,999 Unknown 15 days
10 Frederick Avenue 3 3 2,014 $499,000 $247 12 days
103 Geneva Street 3 2 1,776 $579,000 $326 16 days
Average: 3.6 2.4 1,928 $514,948 $11,460 49 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 113
Viewing 1 - 50 of 113
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
59 Brook Street 5 2 1,677 $460,000 $460,000 $274 92 days 5/17/22
100 Fitchburg Street 3 2 1,607 $619,000 $605,000 $376 15 days 5/16/22
871 Aberdeen Road 4 3 2,032 $659,000 $705,000 $346 19 days 5/13/22
1594 Forks Road 3 2 2,384 $465,000 $460,000 $192 29 days 5/13/22
124 Penataquit Avenue 5 3 N/A $1,100,000 $998,400 Unknown 3 days 5/12/22
9 Michigan Avenue 6 2 N/A $545,000 $535,000 Unknown 50 days 5/12/22
39 Shore Lane 5 3 N/A $450,000 $450,000 Unknown 24 days 5/12/22
1350 Windsor Avenue 3 2 N/A $299,000 $370,000 Unknown 2 days 5/11/22
1393 3rd Avenue 3 2 N/A $450,000 $515,000 Unknown 10 days 5/11/22
225 3rd Avenue 2 2 N/A $379,999 $390,000 Unknown 35 days 5/11/22
208 Brentwood Road 5 4 N/A $675,000 $660,000 Unknown 14 days 5/11/22
101 Saxon Avenue 4 2 1,457 $479,316 $530,000 $363 6 days 5/6/22
43 Shore Lane 7 4 4,700 $984,900 $975,000 $207 26 days 5/6/22
227 Gunther Avenue 3 2 N/A $428,000 $345,000 Unknown 140 days 5/6/22
26 Hemlock Drive 3 2 N/A $429,000 $465,000 Unknown 13 days 5/2/22
1021 Ocean Avenue 3 1 1,139 $450,000 $470,000 $412 20 days 4/29/22
1249 Brookdale Avenue 3 1 N/A $449,999 $455,000 Unknown 20 days 4/29/22
1376 Brooklyn Boulevard 4 2 1,680 $469,000 $520,000 $309 3 days 4/29/22
1099 Thompson Drive 3 1 N/A $465,000 $480,000 Unknown 21 days 4/29/22
72 Sunset Road 3 3 N/A $949,999 $900,000 Unknown 6 days 4/29/22
145 Garden City Street 3 1 N/A $439,990 $458,350 Unknown 40 days 4/28/22
72 Pine Aire Drive 4 3 2,900 $575,000 $620,000 $213 3 days 4/28/22
1590 Thompson Drive 3 1 N/A $500,000 $500,000 Unknown 19 days 4/27/22
1480 Baldwin Boulevard 3 2 N/A $474,999 $500,000 Unknown 31 days 4/27/22
4 Amfer Court 3 1 N/A $465,000 $463,500 Unknown 24 days 4/27/22
1522 Saint Louis Avenue 3 2 1,541 $524,000 $550,000 $356 21 days 4/26/22
1077 Nugent Avenue 3 1 1,248 $349,000 $350,000 $280 76 days 4/26/22
1058 Manor Lane 4 2 3,170 $499,000 $530,000 $167 14 days 4/25/22
39 Connecticut Avenue 6 5 N/A $575,000 $600,000 Unknown 20 days 4/25/22
136 Geneva Street 5 2 N/A $525,000 $565,000 Unknown 14 days 4/22/22
1421 Ackerson Boulevard 3 1 N/A $459,990 $480,000 Unknown 14 days 4/22/22
57 Les Street 3 1 1,200 $489,000 $490,000 $408 28 days 4/22/22
1693 Central Boulevard 3 4 1,027 $425,000 $450,000 $438 0 days 4/21/22
49 Oneill Avenue 5 3 N/A $539,999 $540,000 Unknown 173 days 4/21/22
6 Cambridge Avenue 4 2 N/A $250,000 $225,000 Unknown 155 days 4/20/22
7 Cummings Street 5 3 N/A $599,990 $590,000 Unknown 47 days 4/20/22
1404 Third Avenue 4 2 1,800 $250,000 $225,000 $125 355 days 4/20/22
1774 Wells Drive 3 2 N/A $475,000 $465,000 Unknown 62 days 4/19/22
320 Atlantic Avenue 3 1 1,005 $319,000 $340,000 $338 6 days 4/18/22
23 Tern Court 5 4 3,887 $1,195,000 $1,200,000 $308 19 days 4/15/22
953 Thompson Drive 4 3 2,063 $675,000 $685,000 $332 5 days 4/14/22
1253 Saxon Avenue 4 3 N/A $525,000 $520,000 Unknown 17 days 4/11/22
322 Atlantic Avenue 5 2 N/A $500,000 $500,000 Unknown 11 days 4/11/22
13 Admirals Drive Unit #13 3 3 2,699 $719,000 $650,000 $240 40 days 4/11/22
10 Allen Point Road 3 2 1,550 $699,000 $675,000 $435 112 days 4/11/22
36 Abrew Street 4 2 2,200 $584,900 $579,000 $263 21 days 4/7/22
46 Redmond Avenue 3 2 N/A $399,999 $450,000 Unknown 8 days 4/6/22
9B Hemlock Drive Unit #49 1 1 N/A $99,000 $99,000 Unknown 2 days 4/5/22
162 Boathouse Lane Unit #162 2 3 N/A $579,999 $650,000 Unknown 1 day 4/5/22
1557 Thompson Drive 3 1 N/A $399,000 $415,000 Unknown 9 days 4/5/22
Average: 3.6 2.2 3,299 $527,515 $532,637 $288 40 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 203
Viewing 1 - 50 of 203

Information Copyright 2016, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.