Quick Massapequa NY MLS Search

Browse All Massapequa NY Historical Properties for Sale

$1,199,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 998173 MLS
Nestled in one of the most coveted neighborhoods in the area, this enchanting Old Harbour Green Cape exudes warmth, character, and the kind of charm that simply cannot be replicated. With three spacious bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a beautifully manicured lot that invites you from the moment you arrive, this is more than a home — it’s a rare opportunity. At the center of the kitchen stands an island, and a built in area for extra seating. The fireplace in the kitchen sets the stage for cozy mornings, while a dual fireplace anchors the living room and den. Abundant windows bathe every room in natural light. Gas heating and gas cooking offer efficiency and ease. A one car garage offers additional storage. What truly sets this property apart is its exceptional upside. Architectural plans for renovation and expansion are included - a rare and valuable gift to the discerning buyer ready to put their personal stamp on a home with extraordinary bones. Whether you envision an open-concept update, a master suite addition, or a full reimagining, the potential is boundless. Beyond the property itself, the lifestyle is unmatched. Enjoy access to neighborhood Green Harbour Shore Beach Club, placing waterfront recreation, community, and the best of coastal living right at your doorstep. Homes with this combination of character, location, and potential don't come along too often. Don’t miss your chance to make this your dream home today.

120 Dartmouth Road, Massapequa

$780,000
5 Beds 2 Baths 995696 MLS
Welcome to this spacious 5-bedroom, 2-full-bath Colonial situated on a desirable corner lot in the heart of Massapequa, with a private entrance on quiet Roosevelt Place, and outside of the flood zone. Offering over 2,100 square feet of living space, this well-built home presents an incredible opportunity to update and customize to your personal taste while enjoying a solid layout and outstanding location. The first floor features an entry foyer, formal living room, oversized family room, dining area, bar area, kitchen, and a large recreational room with soaring ceilings that creates the perfect space for entertaining, gatherings, or additional living space. The main level also includes a bedroom, full bathroom, and convenient laundry area. An attached 1-car garage adds additional convenience and storage. Upstairs offers 4 bedrooms and an additional full bathroom. Outdoor space includes a nicely sized patio off the kitchen along with a side yard area adjacent to the rec room, ideal for outdoor entertaining, play space, or relaxing evenings. Perfectly positioned just minutes from the Seaford-Oyster Bay Expressway, Massapequa LIRR station, and the shopping and dining along Merrick Road, this home combines size, location, and potential. Residents also enjoy access to local amenities including Florence Avenue Beach and Anchor Park featuring basketball courts, pickleball, tennis courts, baseball fields, and soccer fields. A fantastic opportunity to create your dream home in a prime Massapequa location.

280 Division Avenue, Massapequa

$1,375,000
6 Beds 4 Baths 900925 MLS
Timeless Charm Meets Modern Comfort in This Restored Circa 1910 Colonial on a Large Corner Property. Enter into a piece of history with this beautifully renovated and meticulously restored three-story Colonial, ideally situated .2 miles from the LIRR station and near the scenic Massapequa Nature Preserve. Greenbelt trails lead directly to Bethpage State Park and then north to route 25, offering the perfect blend of outdoor adventure and tranquil living. This home welcomes you with old world charm. Enter into an enclosed front porch and a grand foyer adorned with intricate wood moldings and hardwood floors—true to its early 20th-century roots. A striking staircase sets the tone for the home’s character and craftsmanship throughout. French doors open into the formal dining room, where high wainscot moldings with built-in decorative ledge, and a stunning stained glass window evoke the charm of the early 1900s. The dining room leads to a beautiful 3-seasons room overlooking the backyard. The living room features rich hardwood floors, a wood-burning brick fireplace (with a hidden time capsule), original stained glass windows, and custom built-in wood bookshelves—perfect for cozy evenings or a refined home library. The sundrenched bonus room with a full bathroom offers views of the backyard oasis, complete with an in-ground pool. Glass doors provide seamless access to the outdoor space, making it ideal for indoor-outdoor entertaining year-round. The eat-in kitchen is both functional and stylish, featuring tile floors, custom cabinetry, stainless steel appliances including a double gas oven and gas range, dishwasher and refrigerator. A feature of the turn of the century is the convenient staircase from the kitchen to the upper level . The second floor hosts a spacious primary ensuite retreat with two closets, a double vanity, a tiled shower, and a very rare private balcony overlooking the property. Three additional bedrooms and a full bathroom complete this level. Ascend to the third floor to find the fifth bedroom, a skylit sixth bedroom, a cedar closet, and a full bathroom with both a soaking tub and separate shower. Enter outside to your own private sanctuary. The fully fenced backyard is beautifully landscaped and designed for both relaxation and entertaining. Enjoy summer days in the in-ground vinyl pool, complete with a fun slide and diving rock. A stunning multi-level brick patio provides ample space for lounging or dining, while the fully equipped outdoor kitchen makes hosting effortless. Whether it’s a quiet morning coffee or a lively evening gathering, this backyard has it all. A full basement provides ample storage or future expansion opportunities. This home blends the charm of its historic roots with the modern comforts today’s lifestyle demands. A rare gem in an unbeatable location that is .2 miles from the LIRR station and even closer to the nature preserve.

399 Ocean Avenue, Massapequa

$825,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 992578 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully maintained and move-in ready open concept home located in the highly sought-after Plainedge School District , just minutes from Tobay Beach. From the moment you enter inside, you’ll appreciate the warm and inviting layout, highlighted by wood floors flowing seamlessly throughout the entire home. The open concept kitchen is truly the heart of the home, featuring a center island, all new stainless steel appliances, gas cooking and high hats - perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen flows effortlessly into the dining area, where sliding glass doors lead to a Trex deck, creating the perfect space for outdoor dining, relaxing, or hosting guests. The spacious living room is filled with natural light from a beautiful bay window and offers a comfortable setting with baseboard heating and wall unit air conditioning. A versatile family room/playroom with a private office and full bathroom provides excellent flexibility for guests, extended living or working from home. The finished basement adds valuable additional living space and includes a washer and dryer for convenience. Upstairs, you’ll find 2 well-sized bedrooms& a full bathroom, along with newer windows that enhance natural light throughout. Additional features include in—ground sprinklers, 150- amp electric service, oil heat & efficient 3-zone heating. Ideally located near shopping, major parkways, and the LIRR, this home offers the perfect combination of comfort, convenience & lifestyle. Don’t miss this incredible opportunity to own a beautiful home I prime Massapequa location! Interior sq footage is approximate. ***Taxes have been grieved and reduced with a successful reduction.

2 Oxford Avenue, Massapequa

$899,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 991435 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully updated Side Hall Colonial in the highly sought-after Nassau Shores waterfront community! Situated on a unique oversized corner lot, this home offers privacy in a vibrant community, standout curb appeal, and classic Colonial charm that’s hard to find still. With just under 2,000 square feet of living space, the home features a thoughtfully designed layout and extensive updates throughout. The entire first floor was fully renovated down to the studs less than 15 years ago, including updated electrical with wiring now in the ceiling. A proper entry foyer with two oversized double closets sets the tone the moment you enter. The main level is complete with radiant heated flooring, high-hat lighting throughout, a versatile bonus room perfect for a home office, and a beautifully updated kitchen featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and an Italian travertine tile backsplash. Hardwood flooring and porcelain tile throughout the home, adding both warmth and durability. Upstairs, you’ll find 4 generously sized bedrooms and a full bathroom that was just completely renovated in March 2026, offering a fresh, modern feel. But the oversized primary ensuite bedroom is the star of the second floor. Two large closets and a full bathroom make it the primary everyone hopes to have. Major updates include a new central AC condenser (4 years), siding (5 years), roof and gutters (6 years), and a boiler less than 15 years old. The home also offers gas heating and cooking, plus an attached garage with brand new electronics and door opener installed in 2026. Enjoy being just moments from the waterfront park at the end of the block, and conveniently located near the Peninsula Golf Course and Riviera Catering Hall. You’re also minutes from John J. Burns Park and Marjorie R. Post Community Park, offering everything from sports fields and skating to pools and year-round community activities. An affordable move-in ready home in one of Massapequa’s most desirable neighborhoods—don’t miss this rare opportunity!

142 E Shore Drive, Massapequa

$725,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 982332 MLS
REDUCED! Hurry! Best buy for possible M/D. Opportunity knocks in a prime location. One of the areas most sought after neighborhoods in the Plainedge School District #18. 1,632sf/ 3-bedroom, 1.5 bath home plus a BONUS room -ideal as a den, home office, or potential fourth bedroom and situated on an oversized corner lot backyard offering privacy and comfort perfect for summer BBQ’s and large scale entertainment. This lovely home is bathed in natural light from its favorable southeast-facing exposure and is accented by hardwood floors throughout. The living room flows into the dining area with a striking beamed ceiling that provides a modern setting for gatherings. The renovated open kitchen offers lots of cabinet space and has granite countertops, a breakfast bar with overhead lighting. The three bedrooms, and the fully renovated bathroom featuring a double vanity and new lighting are located on the upper level, and there is access to a crawl space for added storage. The lower level is finished and offers stunning Hickory wood flooring throughout; a decorative faux fireplace, the BONUS room and an updated half bathroom. The auxiliary area is a separate room that has the washer, dryer, boiler, hot water heater, & electrical panel. The (OSE) separate entrance leads to the large fenced in backyard with a designated patio area, and fire pit area with room for more activity areas. Perfect & balanced for gatherings. There is also a shed for storage. The property is conveniently located near the highway, minutes to shopping centers, dining, parks and more.

1084 Hicksville Road, Massapequa

$749,999
3 Beds 2 Baths 984440 MLS
Welcome to 256 Division Street in Massapequa — a fully renovated inline ranch offering quality craftsmanship, modern upgrades, and a functional layout. This home features 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, with thoughtful finishes throughout. The interior offers an open and inviting layout with wood flooring throughout, enhanced by crown molding, beautiful fixtures, and an abundance of natural light from multiple windows, creating a bright and welcoming atmosphere.The updated kitchen includes modern cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, quartz countertop and ample space for everyday living and entertaining.The bathrooms have been recently renovated, feature heated floors on the main level, custom vanities, and glass shower enclosures, providing a clean and modern design. The fully finished basement offers additional usable space with epoxy flooring, a dehumidifier system, and generous storage. The home is also equipped with French drains and dual sump pumps. Step into a fully designed outdoor living space that offers both style and functionality. The backyard features a beautifully crafted heated above-ground pool with a beautiful waterfall surrounded by elegant brickwork and custom stone finishes, creating a clean and modern look.The space is enhanced with a custom-built outdoor kitchen, complete with a built-in grill, sink, and storage — ideal for entertaining and everyday outdoor use. A covered gazebo with electric adds additional comfort and flexibility, perfect for relaxing or hosting gatherings. The entire yard is finished with paver stone throughout, providing a low-maintenance and cohesive outdoor environment. Thoughtfully designed and well-maintained, this outdoor area offers a complete extension of the home’s living space. Additional upgrades include 200-amp electrical service. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, and transportation options, including access to the LIRR. Commute time to New York City is approximately 45–60 minutes via train, depending on schedule. Close to major roadways including Sunrise Highway and the Southern State Parkway. A move-in-ready home with extensive updates, modern features, and strong overall value.

256 Division Avenue, Massapequa

$925,000
980709 MLS
**MULTIPLE OFFERS** BEST OFFERS THURSDAY 4/23/26. Prime commercial building with 3 RETAIL spaces, a large fenced-in LOT behind the building and a GARAGE. Highly visible on Broadway in Massapequa (Oyster Bay). This property extends all the way to Franklin Avenue. The front RETAIL structure is currently configured with THREE RETAIL storefronts. Ideal for an owner-user to occupy one of the Retail spaces while collecting rental income from the other Retail spaces in addition the back LOT and GARAGE can be source of income or repurposed for another use. The large fenced-in LOT in the rear, which can be used for parking, storage, outdoor display, contractor yard, or future development potential. This type of outdoor space is extremely rare on Broadway and adds significant value and flexibility for many types of businesses. Additionally, the property offers a potential for a residential building lot with Town approval. This property is ideal for Investors, Developers, or Owner-Users. This is a rare opportunity to own a versatile commercial property with income, land, and future development potential in a prime Massapequa location. Located .06 of a mile to Sunrise Highway with Traffic Count of 53,984. Located 1 mile to Southern State Parkway with a Traffic Count of 162,494. Walking distance to the Train (.22 of a mile). This property offers exceptional exposure with strong daily traffic counts, making it ideal for retail, office, development/residential or investment use. Custom built by the owner, FIRST time on the market! PUBLIC SEWER and PUBLIC WATER. Note: Addresses for RETAIL spaces are 561, 563 and 565 Broadway + LOT/GARAGE Broadway. All Tenants are Month to Month. Rental income: 561 - $23,520.00 563 - $31,468.00 565 - $ 35,005.00 (Salon)-now vacant LOT/Garage: $10,800. Income includes the hair salon through December 2025. No NNN charges ONLY tax increases. Owner has only increased the rent over the past 10 years to cover tax increases. Expenses 2025: Taxes $33,046.68 Insurance: $4790 Water: $330 Professional Fees: $850

565 Broadway, Massapequa

$769,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 979990 MLS
Buyers wait anxiously for a 2 car oversized garage, with access to the interior of the home, and a full basement ranch, like this to come to market. Nestled on a corner lot along a quiet, tree-lined street, this charming home welcomes you with well-manicured landscaping and a classic blue slate stoop. Designed for comfort and functionality, this ranch offers easy one-floor living, with additional space in a finished basement. Step inside to a tiled foyer that gracefully separates the entry from the spacious living room and dining room, where hardwood floors lie beneath the existing carpeting. The kitchen is filled with natural light from its windows and offers wonderful potential for the next owner to make it their own, with direct access to the back deck for easy indoor-outdoor living. There is easy access to the garage from a door in the dining room. A full attic is easily accessible from the garage. The primary bedroom features its own updated bath, while the main bath remains original yet has been impeccably maintained. Two additional bedrooms are situated along the same wide hallway, offering a practical and inviting layout. The basement spans the full length of the home, with half already finished, creating the perfect space for entertaining, a game room, or additional living area for everyone to enjoy. Outside, the fenced backyard has been lovingly cared for and provides a peaceful setting to relax on the deck while overlooking the pretty yard. Located in the highly regarded Plainedge School District and offering all the amenities of the Town of Oyster Bay, including Tobay Beach, parks, restaurants, and shopping, this home is a wonderful opportunity to enjoy comfortable living in a prime location.

46 Bedford Avenue, Massapequa

$599,999
3 Beds 2 Baths 977564 MLS
Welcome to this sun-drenched, impeccably maintained 3-bedroom, 2 full bathroom home, perfectly situated on the South Shore in Massapequa, just minutes from South Oyster Bay. Set on an expansive .32-acre lot, this property offers both immediate comfort and incredible potential. This home features a new roof, boiler, plumbing, electrical, windows, and siding, delivering peace of mind for years to come. The spacious, modern kitchen is designed to impress, showcasing stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops, and plenty of room to gather and entertain. Both bathrooms have been tastefully renovated with a clean, contemporary aesthetic. A flexible bonus space provides the perfect opportunity for a home office, den, or laundry area, while the detached one-car garage adds everyday convenience with its own electric panel and could also be perfect for a workshop. Step outside to your fully fenced backyard with an oversized outdoor retreat ideal for relaxing, entertaining, or creating your own private oasis. With ample space and endless possibilities, this yard is truly a standout feature. Enjoy the location with the added protection and benefit of a low-cost flood protection insurance of $2,252.00 annually. Peace of mind included! Tucked away on a quiet street, yet just moments from the beach, parks, shopping, dining, and transportation, this location offers the best of South Shore living. Move right in and enjoy, this is the home you have been waiting for!

27 E Lincoln Avenue, Massapequa

$1,199,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 971231 MLS
Welcome to this stunning expanded ranch located in the highly sought-after Harbor Green community of Massapequa. This spacious 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offers the ideal blend of comfort, functionality, and modern upgrades. Inside you'll find beautiful hardwood floors, high ceilings, and an abundance of natural light pouring through large windows, including charming stained-glass accents. The open and inviting layout features a formal dining room, a well-appointed home office, and a dedicated gym space to fit today’s lifestyle needs. The heart of the home is the gourmet kitchen, complete with a center island, stainless steel appliances, a convenient pot filler, and large doors to enter out to the yard—perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The first-floor primary bedroom offers ultimate convenience with a private ensuite bath and a walk-in closet. A first-floor laundry room also adds to the home’s ease of living. Additional highlights include central air conditioning, gas heating and cooking, solar panels for energy efficiency, a full-house generator, alarm system, water filtration system, built-in dehumidifier, sprinkler system, and a French drain system. Outside, enjoy a private backyard oasis featuring large deck and hot tub, along with a spacious two-car garage that is heated and plumbed. Harbor Green residents have private access to the Harbour Green Shores Club. Memberships include the beach club, pool, marina, weekly events, & more. Also ideally located near parks, train, shopping, dining, shopping, and more—this home truly has it all. Don’t miss your opportunity to live in one of Massapequa’s most desirable neighborhoods!

301 Cameo Drive, Massapequa

$997,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 972184 MLS
Welcome to this beautiful sprawling ranch in the highly sought-after Biltmore Shores community. This home showcases stunning architectural details, including a reverse gable roof and low-maintenance PVC trim throughout. Set on an impressive 13,800 sq ft property (120 x 126 irregular), the home offers exceptional curb appeal with a beautifully designed walkway and oversized driveway accommodating 6+ cars. The exterior features cedar-impression vinyl siding, custom cultured stone accents, and a striking chimney. A welcoming front stoop with detailed railings sets the tone for what’s inside. Step inside to a warm and inviting layout featuring a cozy wood-burning fireplace that flows seamlessly into the dining area. The updated eat-in kitchen boasts granite countertops, ample cabinetry, gas cooking and a large pantry. In-ground Sprinklers, 200 Amps & Hardwood Floors. The family room is filled with natural light from Andersen windows and a sliding door overlooking the spectacular backyard. The primary bedroom offers two closets and a private en-suite bath. The expansive basement. The oversized 2-car garage features soaring 10+ ft ceilings—perfect for storage or car enthusiasts. The backyard is truly exceptional, featuring Cambridge paver patios, including one with a custom stone outdoor fireplace—ideal for entertaining. The fully fenced PVC yard is beautifully landscaped and includes gated access for a boat or trailer. Enjoy all that Biltmore Shores has to offer, including a private beach club with amenities such as an in-ground pool, playground, and marina access. Home is X Flood Zone-Home does not require flood Insurance.

20 Biltmore Boulevard, Massapequa

$1,949,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 941656 MLS
Stunning new construction underway in Biltmore Shores! Offering 3,600 sq ft plus an additional 1,400 sq ft new foundation basement with outside entrance—nearly 5,000 sq ft of total space. Ideally positioned on the block, this modern colonial delivers exceptional craftsmanship throughout with a stunning modern layout. The first floor welcomes you with a dramatic double-height foyer, formal dining room highlighted by a decorative ceiling and custom cabinetry open living room showcases elegant applied moldings, while oversized luxury casement windows flood the home with natural light. A spacious first-floor bedroom/office with its own full bath ideal for guests or extended family. The chef’s kitchen is the heart of the home with gas cooking, an enormous double-sided island and waterfall countertops, stainless steel appliances, HIDDEN walk-in pantry, and a pot filler. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the family room, complete with a gas fireplace and oversized accordion style sliders leading to professionally landscaped yard perfect for indoor/outdoor entertaining. Additional first-floor features include 9-ft ceilings, 4" white oak hardwood floors, and custom crown molding. The second floor offers four oversized bedrooms, including a serene primary suite with a decorative ceiling, two walk-in closets, and a spa-like bathroom. An additional ensuite bedroom, two more bedrooms with a large family bath, and a laundry room complete the level.

81 Bayview Avenue, Massapequa

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

Massapequa Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Massapequa and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!